The world of vintage has exploded, driven by a desire for sustainability and unique, one-of-a-kind pieces. While clothes and bags have long been the focus, a new category is taking center stage: vintage shoes. One Vogue editor recently went on a quest to find her dream Miuccia Prada Mary Janes from the Fall 2012 collection, a design so iconic it was “re-edited” for a modern show. But when the reissue didn’t happen, she turned to the vintage market.
For many, wearing vintage is a way to express individuality and own a piece of fashion history. But while a vintage dress can be a treasure, shoes present a unique challenge. Unlike clothes, shoes mold to the wearer’s foot and are exposed to the elements, making them a more personal—and potentially “icky”—purchase.
The Art of Finding and Restoring Vintage Footwear
Finding vintage shoes in pristine condition is a rare feat. Brit Blanco-Bird, co-founder of the vintage store Treasures of NYC, notes that shoes endure more physical wear and tear than any other vintage category. This means a great find often requires some love and care.
But don’t be deterred. With the right approach, a pair of worn vintage shoes can be restored to their former glory. Spasia Dimitrievska, founder of the online shop Fivedotsvintage, offers a key piece of advice: “The first thing I do is check to see what can be fixed.” She recommends replacing the heel cap, a tell-tale sign of wear, and using a good cobbler to fix small scratches. With a little work, a well-made vintage shoe can be salvaged and even feel brand new.
Sizing and Fit: A Vintage Shoe Conundrum
Beyond condition, fit can be a major hurdle. Sizing and manufacturing have evolved, and a vintage shoe may not feel the same as a modern one. Brynn Jones Saban, owner of Aralda Vintage in Los Angeles, points out that while the basic construction of heels hasn’t changed much, modern shoes can sometimes offer more comfort.
It’s also worth noting that many high-end vintage shoes were likely considered special-occasion footwear when they were first purchased. They weren’t meant for everyday wear and tear, which explains why some well-preserved designer pairs have survived for decades.
The hunt for vintage shoes is not for the faint of heart, but for those willing to put in the effort, it can lead to a truly unique addition to their wardrobe.
